The Notebook Nerd
(formerly "The Notebook Buyer's HomePage")
This site has been evolved (and will no longer be updated)...
Please visit
gadtronics.com

Serving the Net since 1997
Home

Buying Tips

Reviews

Links

Message Board

About

Click here!
Make money
from clicks
Please visit our sponsors.
Click Here to Visit our Sponsor

Sprint PCS Phone Review

Aug 12, 2003: Erick's review of the Samsung A620 (VGA1000) w/ comparisons to the Sanyo 5300
This is a work in progress so check back every once in a while as I will be adding things here and there. If you have any comments or questions, please leave them at the SprintUsers.com forum.

(I didn't compress the pictures so they may take a while to load)

Update 08/13/03: Added pictures from the A620 with Fine setting

Comparison to the Sanyo 5300
Since my current (and soon to be former phone) is the 5300, I've posted some comparison pictures for you:


Side by side comparison (hehe... still had the plastic on the A620). As you can see, the body of the 5300 is longer than the A620, but overall length is not that much different because of the long antenna of the A620.



Thickness is almost exactly the same


I like the layout of the Samsung keys much better than the Sanyo


Since the flash illuminated the fronts much more than normally, you can actually see the LCD of the Sanyo in "off" mode. In reality, the Samsung's external LCD in "off" mode is much easier to see.


Ahh.. those green LEDs. However, notice how much brighter the Samsung's is (the one on the right).

The A620 does weigh a bit heavier than the 5300, it's only 2 or 3 ounces but for some reason it is noticeable. There are some other differences I noticed:
  • Samsung's menu system is much easier to use (and much nicer looking) than Sanyo's.
  • When in camera mode, the 5300 has better tracking, on the A620, the image is a little delayed.
  • I like the way the keys feel better on the Samsung, the 5300 keys were a little flat and this caused miskeys.
  • I don't see too much of a difference in main LCD screen quality and color, but that's me.
  • Although menu navigation is faster on the A620, going through picture review area is slower.
  • But... picture saving on the A620 is MUCH faster than the 5300
Camera position
I've posted this before but I really like where they positioned the camera on the A620. Instead of on the front like most of the other folder phones, it's on the top portion of the back of the phone. By doing this, it allows you to take pictures while the phone is closed using the external LCD. In addition, if you can tell by the pictures, the camera is tilted at an angle that is parallel to the front lid of the phone when it is open giving you the same type of positioning as if it were on the front lid. This also helps in self-portrait mode because it allows you see the external LCD while pointing the camera at you (with the lid open of course).



Case/Holster
Some people were lucky enough to get a Body Glove holster with their phones (when you buy from Costco, you get an accessory pack which includes a car charger, ear bud and case/holster). At my local SoCal Costco (Fountain Valley), I got this leather holster-slash-case-slash-doodoo thing. It only goes over the back part of the phone held by that see-through plastic and the loop over the antenna. Then you snap it into the belt clip and voila... crappy case/holster combination (at least in my opinion).


Since I hated that thing and I couldn't find the Body Glove case that other *lucky* Costco buyers got, I went out and bought this "universal" holster at one of those cell phone accesories kiosks in the mall. I like it because it doesn't have the velcro/snap/magnetic flap that other holsters have and it fit the A620 (and the 5300 for that matter) perfectly. I was using one of those full leather cases for the 5300 but I couldn't take pictures with the phone because although it had a hole for the camera, it wasn't quite at the right spot when the phone was opened. Now I can just slip the phone in and out of the holster.

Plus this holster had the low profile clip (I wear the phone on the inside of my pants pocket) so it's not that thick.

Camera pictures comparison
Here are the pictures and now I know why I was having framing problems when taking pictures. The 5300 takes pictures in portrait mode (480x640) and the A620 takes it in landscape mode (640x480). This kind of makes sense because the 5300 LCD is taller than it is wide and the A620 puts status bars on the top and bottom of the screen so the viewable area is wider than it is tall. You'll see what I mean when you see the pics, the 5300 is first, the A620 is second.



Close up


My Dell 4150


Young guava tree


Picture of my Optio-S using flash


Low light picture of CD tower


Outdoor picture of trees

As you can see, the 5300 seems to have clearer pictures. For some reason the A620 pics look cloudy, maybe I have the wrong settings but I decided just to use the default so you can compare The A620 does take better low light pictures as the 5300 has that vertical line problem but colors and clarity seem to be much better on the 5300. Maybe there is something I can do to make the A620 pictures look less blurry. You can also notice the ring of darkness on the A620 pictures similar to the ring of blur in 8100 pictures.

Update 08/13/03:
I've added some more pictures from the A620. These are using 'Fine' quality which I don't think really affected it much. When you look at them on their own, they are pretty good (as long as you don't have them next to pictures from the 5300.. hehe)






Conclusion
So... the picture quality of the A620 in my opinion is not as good as the 5300, but overall, I think the phone has superior features. The browser speed is much faster but the smaller screen gives you less to see and I can't find a font setting for the browser. The menu system is way easier to use and by adding number shortcuts to the menus, it makes going through them faster. I do think the screen is more readable but that may be due to the fact that I had the 5300 in a case and the plastic distorted it. The voice recognition functions alone is enough to make me keep this over the 5300. I'll post more thoughts once I play with it more but for now I think I'll be a 1k baller (sorry... inside joke).

6624
Favorite Links

Sponsored Links
Dell Notebooks
Fujitsu Notebooksicon

Refurbs/Auctions
Dell Outlet icon
HP/Compaq
UBid

Accessories
LapDesk 2.0
Great accessory for on the go or at your desk!
Atek
Nice mini USB optical mouse
Road Tools
I use their CoolPad all the time

more...

Special Offers From Dell Home Systems

Dell Centrino/Pentium-M Notebook

Click to buy!

New Dell Inspiron 8500 - Widescreen Notebook


Click to buy!

Banner 10000053


Home • Tips • Reviews • Links • Message Board • About
Special Offers From Dell Computers

Banner 10000051

Get Hosted by EdgeWorld
EdgeWorld